Those who know me would say, “Of course!” Let’s get serious. What does being an anarchist mean? Are we the same as libertarians? We share so many of the same values, it’s really hard to tell, but the difference is how we get to the end result of the government falling away. Karl Marx developed the theory that labor would organize itself, and labor unions would run the government. That’s it in a nutshell. As we Jews say, the rest is commentary. This was at a time when labor was not really organized, and the thought was that labor would organize as industrial unions, not business unions, like what we actually have.
Anarchists don’t believe in no government. They believe in small government—like the libertarians do. We aren’t generally violent people, although the writers of American history would have us believe Sacco & Vanzetti were bomb throwers (it couldn’t possibly have been the police starting a riot…)
I came to anarchism through industrial unionism… syndicalism…and the Industrial Workers of the World. For those who don’t know anything about the Wobblies, you might get Patrick Renshaw’s book, or rent Warren Beatty’s movie, Reds (which is part documentary & interviews with old Wobs, as we were called).
We believe workers should run the economy…the government, and that the boss is useless. I would general digress now about how difficult it is for dog groomers to work for non-dog groomers who are business owners, and who want to exploit our labor, but this is not why I am blogging about anarchism.
The problem is…that our needs in modern, urban, society are complicated and require full time oversight. This would leave little time for economic activity to support our community’s needs: planning, developing, and caring for infrastructure, energy resources, schools and education, health care, security, and information communication and distribution.
So—we have an overlay of bureaucracy to take care of stuff’. They have to get paid, so we tax ourselves.
But then..the dynamic changes, and the politicians we elect seem to think that they really provide an added value, as do the employees they oversee that are working for us. They get much better benefits than the rest of us, including their pension plans…and the result is, of course, that so many government entities are now declaring bankruptcy.
I am an old lady now. The billions we could have spent on teaching teachers to teach science, to provide health car cradle to grave, to develop and renewable energy resources… we spend on the wars in Viet Nam, Nicaragua, Iraq, and Afghanistan, Bosnia, Somalia (but not Rwanda)…so people could be free? We allowed the people we elected to underfund out schools, pander to teachers’ unions (how ironic is this?)deny us health care as a human right (unless we live to be very old), bail out banks & AIG—the insurance company too big to fail—in place of environmental and economic security…what is this about?
We parrot that the USA is the greatest country in the world, and we are, essentially, as bad as the Russians: buffoons to the rest of the world.
I am not sure what the solution is, but now that we have the internet, I would think it would be easier for people to get more information and be a little skeptical about what we all think is the conventional wisdom.