I recently read Colleen Hoover’s It Ends With Us. It’s a story about a woman who grew up with an abusive father. He dies, leaves her an inheritance, she opens a florists shop, and she meets a man ‘with issues’, marries him, he’s abusive, and she has to make a decision. That’s the gist.
I read the book because it was published several years ago, was featured on ‘Book Tok,” and became a best seller. In fact, all of Hoover’s books are now best sellers, partially because of BookTok and word of mouth.
I was out and picked up a student newspaper where a student reviewer gave the book a ‘Don’t bother to read’ review. She felt it wasn’t realistic. sShe says she read the book in four hours. Yes, the antagonist is a medical student with a brilliant career ahead of him. There are lots of books about abusers who are handsome and have good jobs and women who make excuses for the guy they love. But the fact that she couldn’t put the book down said a lot to me.
If you read a several hundred page book in four hours, it’s a compelling read—realistic or not. I’ve started to read so many books, gotten 20 pages in, and decided either the book is going nowhere, or it’s a waste of time. I’ve read two of Susan Choi’s books, and boy, she uses a lot of words to tell a story—whether believable or not. I don’t like books that I have to read a sentence two or three times to figure out what the writer is saying—but for many, that’s ‘literary fiction’. Like Murakani’s “Wind Up Bird Chronicle’. Did it really have to be that many words with that many tangents?
Nobody wants to read a book about the girls who allowed themselves to be picked up in a bar, or linked up with a friend-of-a-friend, who left them pregnant, and the girl and kid have to struggle. Our own lives have enough angst.
Last year, I reviewed “Inappropriate Men“, by Stacey Ballis (https://wordpress.com/post/disparateinterests.wordpress.com/4998). I’m sure you can still get it on Amazon. The main character, who describes herself as a fat girl, has a torrid affair with her father’s business partner who she knows won’t leave his wife, then a series of other inappropriate men who aren’t suitable long term partners for other reasons. I found this funny and accurate. I’m sure many women have dated men and at some point realized the relationship was going nowhere, they really weren’t that attracted to the guy, or were settling because they wanted to be married.
I picked up “One to Watch” by Kate Stayman-London partly because of the back cover blurb; Bea is a large size fashion blogger with a following, who is asked to be on a show based on The Bachelor. She’d hesitant for good reason, and of course, most of the men are dogs. If you live in the USA and haven’t seen The Bachelor, you’re living in a cave. All the girls they pick are always a size 6 or smaller, long haired, none wear glasses, and all are fashion forward. The men are all good looking and shallow. In any case, this book does have a happy ending, and it also addresses the issues most of us face when looking for a partner. I’d give this book to teenage girls.