I am a secular Jew. I was raised as a Reform Jew. That means we don’t do the daily or weekly rituals. How do Reform Jews raise their children? We’re taught the gist of the Old Testament (“The Bible”) stories, and many of us celebrate the ‘High’ holidays (Rosh Hashana/Yom Kippur…& later, Pesach), but the gist is that there is one God. Jesus may have existed, but he’s not ‘special’. We don’t believe in virgin birth… we’re all God’s children.
We’re told the one God we believe in is the same God the Christians and Muslims believe in, but we believe God is inside us–our conscience. We are the chosen people, but Sikh people also believe God is inside us. More, Sikh believe women and men are equal (Jews believe women are separate but equal). We also believe in altruism like the Sikh do. Altruism is important for our communities—not for future reward in the afterlife.
It wasn’t until I was an adult, and read the Bible (several different translations into English) that I learned that Jews kept slaves—but we were to release them in the jubilee year. I also read so many contradictions.
We were Zionists by default. My parents married in the early 1950s, and it was important to them to live near other Jews. Skokie, a suburb of Chicago, was open to Jews. They could get mortgages and home owners insurance. So, I lived in a tolerant, secular appearing community.
My parents joined a synagogue, and we bought trees for Israel.
It wasn’t until I was a teenager, and got a goyem boyfriend (and also went to visit an acquaintance in rural Illinois) that I understood that we Jews were different….from Christians. I just didn’t know how, or why. Was it only because we didn’t believe only Jesus was the child of God? You may notice, in the New Testament—-it’s disciples expounding—not God.
The goyem— Christians, tell us they believe that Jesus was Jewish, and we Jews killed Jesus by betraying him. I still don’t understand the logic, but in the era of Trump, it’s a little more clear.
What we believe, in terms of philosophy, doesn’t really matter as much as how we manifest out beliefs. Jews support Israel because we have no other place to go (we believe) if goyem come after us. Actually, we could go to Buddhist countries, but a small group of Zionists—many of whom were atheist (which also angers goyem) convinced the anti-semites in Europe that they should help us take over Palestine politically, with violence, if necessary.
We have Israel due to anti-semitism. It seems we believed the myth that Palestine was sparsely populated, and the land belonged only to Jews.That’s what our parents taught us: The whole of Palestine was a desert, barren, and the Jews made it bloom.
The reality was different, of course. I recently started reading Jonathan Schneer’s “The Balfour Declaration” https://www.amazon.com/Balfour-Declaration-Origins-Arab-Israeli-Conflict/dp/0812976037 (2010 Random House), which adds detail to both T.E. Lawrence’s and Scott Anderson’s (Lawrence in Arabia) accounts of how this mess came to be.
The British have a lot to answer for, but the gist is that they did not respect the Arabs who controlled the land, and made promises they had no intention of keeping. Yet, they are off the hook, choosing to put their money into the monarchy. In the 21st century. totally silent about the hatred they fomented.
As many have pointed out, Gaza could have been developed like Singapore or Hong Kong, but the hatred the Palestinians had for the usurpers (Jews) combined with their cultural reality has made it so I don’t think the dynamics can be fixed. Their anger should be aimed at the British, but how would they know why this happened? They didn’t have radios, they couldn’t read English newspapers even if they were available. Suddenly, they were invaded—first, just by settlers, then by the British military. The movie, “Exodus” (based on the book by Leon Uris (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exodus_(Uris_novel) makes the founding of Israel seen so romantic. In fact, it was brutal and messy.
Would the British fund reparations to the families that lost their land? Shouldn’t they?
As far as giving Israel back—not gonna happen. i believe the disputed territories should be returned, but I don’t live in Israel. More, I live on Native American land. We have a lot to answer for, but let me state right now that prayer to God—or Jesus, is a waste of time